Interested in sharing the research? You can order print copies of many research publications.

Order Reprints

Newsletter Sign-Up

Keep up to date with NPC news and events by signing up for our e-newsletter E.V.I.dently, and our CER Daily Newsfeed.

Subscribe POLICY

Setting Priorities for Comparative Effectiveness Research: From Assessing Public Health Benefits to Being Open With the Public

Abstract (from Health Affairs): Medicine’s current evidence base is insufficient for many of the decisions made daily by clinicians, patients, purchasers, and policy makers. The Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI) represents an effort by the US government to address this shortcoming by funding comparative effectiveness research (CER). Prioritizing that research will be a critical first step. To better understand components of an optimal process, NPC reviewed the literature and conducted interviews regarding the prioritization efforts of leading public and private health organizations in the United States and abroad. From this review, NPC proposes a framework for prioritization, poses and answers key questions, and makes recommendations regarding application of that framework. NPC also recommends that during the priority-setting process, there should be transparent conversations among those who make decisions about the priorities and the public.

 

View the interview with NPC Chief Science Officer Dr. Robert Dubois and read the press release.

 

About the project:

NPC undertook this research to understand the components of an optimal approach to prioritizing CER. It is especially timely because PCORI is working on its priorities for the CER that it will fund; these priorities will set the tone for all of the institute’s future activities.The research also highlights the difficult questions PCORI will face as the public dialogue on its national research priorities and research agenda begins.

Why prioritization is important:

Not all topics can be studied; there are budget and time constraints that limit what activities can be done. Without setting criteria or defining priorities, one risks including all areas and prioritizing none, an outcome that is not helpful to patients or providers who are looking for answers.

Key recommendations that should be used to make research decision-making processes more effective include:

  • Defining priorities to identify what has greater and lesser importance;
  • Ensuring that all stakeholders are engaged in all aspects of the prioritization process, including identifying topics and prioritizing among them;
  • Using a systematic approach when considering all evidence as it relates to prioritizing topics;
  • Maintaining an open and transparent consensus process which can handle inevitable disagreement;
  • Communicating the process and the results of the process;
  • Allowing for the incorporation of new evidence that takes into account continuing advances in medical care or technology; and
  • Evaluating the results of the process by asking both those involved in the process and the general public. 
Newsletter Volume

E.V.I.dently June 2015

NPC MessageDriving Health System Value Through Broader Access to DataFrom Fitbits to insurance claims databases, we capture an enormous amount of...
Blog Post

NPC Comments on ASCO Value Framework

The American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) on Monday released a conceptual framework--“A Framework to Assess the Value of Cancer Treatment...
Blog Post

CER Tweets of the Week: CER in the New York Times, AcademyHealth’s Stakeholder Engagement Resources (June 8-12)

This week, comparative effectiveness research (CER) stakeholders shared a @Health_Affairs blog post on how CER can help institutional review boards...
Blog Post

CER Tweets of the Week: CMS at Health Datapalooza, #ASCO15 (June 1-5)

This week, comparative effectiveness research (CER) stakeholders tweeted the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ (@CMSGov) announcement...
Press Release

NPC Comments on CMS’ Announcement to Allow Broader Access to Publicly Funded Databases

(Washington, DC, June 2, 2015)—The National Pharmaceutical Council (NPC) today commented on the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ (CMS)...
Press Release

State Medicaid Directors Share Views on Comparative Effectiveness Research And Its Impact on Policy in National Pharmaceutical Council Survey

(Washington, DC, April 16, 2015)—A new survey conducted on behalf of the National Pharmaceutical Council (NPC) shows that state Medicaid directors...
Press Release

NPC Highlights Stakeholder Views on Comparative Effectiveness Research and the Environment for Health Care Decision-Making

(Washington, DC, March 26, 2015)—A new survey of health care stakeholders reveals continued optimism that comparative effectiveness research (CER)...
Press Release

Fellowship in Health Care Policy Available Through a Partnership of the National Pharmaceutical Council and Milken Institute School of Public Health at The George Washington University

WASHINGTON, DC (September 17, 2014)–The National Pharmaceutical Council (NPC), in conjunction with Milken Institute School of Public Health (Milken...
Commentary and Testimony Page

Chain Drug Review – Commentary: “Health Care Outlook for 2015”

This commentary was originally published in the January 5, 2015 issue of Chain Drug Review.By: Dan Leonard, President, National Pharmaceutical...
Commentary and Testimony Page

NPC Comments on PCORI Proposal for Peer Review of Primary Research and Public Release of Research Findings

November 7, 2014Dr. Joe SelbyExecutive DirectorPatient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute1828 L St., NW, Suite 900Washington, DC 20036Dear Dr....
Commentary and Testimony Page

The State of CER and the Environment for Health Care Decision Making

This month, NPC released its third annual survey on stakeholders’ views on comparative effectiveness research (CER), “The State of Comparative...
Commentary and Testimony Page

Keeping Our Eye on the CER Ball

Until the cherry blossoms begin to bloom later next month, most of the water cooler conversations in Washington will focus on the federal budget....
YouTube Videos

Comparative Effectiveness Research and the Environment for Health Care Decision-Making

During a March 26, 2015 webinar, the National Pharmaceutical Council discussed the results of its annual stakeholder survey on comparative...
YouTube Videos

Why are quality measures important? We asked health care thought leaders to tell us why.

Quality measurement, tied to financial incentives, is one of many approaches accountable care programs are using to promote system-wide improvement....
YouTube Videos

Real-World Impact of Comparative Effectiveness Research Findings on Clinical Practice

National Pharmaceutical Council Chief Science Officer Robert W. Dubois, MD, PhD, discusses a peer-reviewed study suggesting that changes are needed...
YouTube Videos

Using Real-World Evidence to Increase Health Care Access, Improve Quality & Reduce Costs

Mitchell Sugarman, vice president of health economics, policy and payment at Medtronic Cardiac and Vascular Group, explains that health care decision...
Blog Post

NPC Comments on ASCO Value Framework

The American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) on Monday released a conceptual framework--“A Framework to Assess the Value of Cancer Treatment...
Blog Post

CER Tweets of the Week: CER in the New York Times, AcademyHealth’s Stakeholder Engagement Resources (June 8-12)

This week, comparative effectiveness research (CER) stakeholders shared a @Health_Affairs blog post on how CER can help institutional review boards...
Blog Post

CER Tweets of the Week: CMS at Health Datapalooza, #ASCO15 (June 1-5)

This week, comparative effectiveness research (CER) stakeholders tweeted the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ (@CMSGov) announcement...
Blog Post

CER Tweets of the Week: NPC’s Dr. Dubois in JCER, AcademyHealth’s Data Quality Collaborative Projects (May 25-29)

This week, comparative effectiveness research (CER) stakeholders tweeted the latest column from National Pharmaceutical Council (@npcnow) Chief...
  •  
  • 1 of 43
  • >